So, the other day I pointed out that since Joe Carter's World Series winning homerun, no Toronto team has played for a championship. That 16-year drought, I hypothesized, had to be among the longest current droughts of any major sports city in North America (major = a minimum of three pro sports teams in the metropolitan area).
Here is a list again of the top (or bottom) cities:
LONGEST CURRENT TITLE APPEARANCE DROUGHT
Minneapolis / St. Paul 18 years
Toronto 16 years
Washington D.C. 11 years
Milwaukee / Green Bay 11 years
Atlanta 10 years
*minimum 3 pro sports franchises
Well, I decided to expand on the analysis a bit, and use playoff appearances since that Carter homerun as the barometer to rank these cities. First, a couple points of emphasis:
1. I understand not all playoff spots are created equal. MLB (8 / 30) & NFL (12 / 32) have drastically tougher paths to the post-season than NHL (16 / 30) & NBA (16 / 30). For the most part, this should even out but in some instances, it will be either a mitigating or exacerbating factor.
2. I don't really think this is a "better" way to gauge a city's sport success, just "another" way of doing it. The reason I say this: I'll take a team that misses the playoffs for a few years then comes back and actually competes for a title, rather than a team that is consistently getting knocked out of the playoffs in the first round. That being said, this is still another piece of (somewhat) valuable information.
3. After taking a look at a few Google maps, I've made the following geographical decisions: The Charlotte area does not qualify as a three-sport metro area. The Hurricanes are based in Raleigh, nearly three hours away from Charlotte. I'm using the "reasonable drive test" as my barometer for judging whether a team is "local" and the 'Canes fail that test.
4. I've grouped all of the nine Greater NYC teams into one giant conglomerate. Initially, I had the Devils, Nets, and Giants as a New Jersey area trio, but, I mean, the Giants and Jets play in the same damn stadium, so it's tough to separate them into different metro areas.
5. The Bay Area includes the San Jose Sharks (using the "reasonable drive" test, the Sharks are less than an hour away -- about 38 miles), giving them the Sharks, A's, Giants, 49ers, Raiders, and Warriors.
6. I'm torn (well, as torn as you can be about something like this) about whether to include Milwaukee as a qualified area. Green Bay is about 97 miles away from Milwaukee. Let's use 100 miles as our breaking point. It's in! (as the people of Wisconsin rejoice!)
RESULTS
So, we're left with 22 metropolitan areas that are home to 84 pro sports franchises. I won't list them all here, but I'll show you the top & bottom
THE BEST
1. Boston 57% playoff success rate
2. St. Louis 56%
3. Detroit 54%
4. New York 53%
T5. Dallas 52%
T5. Philadelphia 52%
T7. Denver 49%
T7. Pittsburgh 49%
There you have it. Just six cities have a collection of teams that make the playoffs more than half of the time. I have to say when you factor in this result with number of championships won, I think it's pretty clear that Boston is the best sports city in North America right now (which is painful to say because of how excruciating it is to listen to Boston sports fans, the real ones and the ones who are only fans because they think it's cool to be a Boston fan).
I don't think there's any major surprises on this list, other than to say it's impressive that St. Louis and Pittsburgh are on this list, given they're the only cities in the top 8 playing in only one of the two "easy" leagues to make the playoffs (NHL & NBA). Pittsburgh is actually 0-for-14 in baseball, but makes up for it with their outstanding NFL performance (over 70%). St. Louis' impressive totals stems from their 50% success rate in baseball (only Boston, the Yankees, and Atlanta have a higher success rate).
THE WORST
18. Cleveland 37%
T19. Chicago 35%
T19. Washington 35%
21. Toronto 33%
22. Tampa Bay 31%
Before we get to Toronto (and what this result means for the city), I want to talk about some big surprises here (in my opinion). Chicago, I think, is known a pretty good sports town, but they've been awful over the last 15 years. The Hawks have made the playoffs just six times, the Cubs and White Sox collectively have gone to the post-season just seven times, the Bears just four times, and the Bulls nine times. Now I understand why the city was so excited about the Blackhawks rebirth this past season.
Washington is also a pretty depressing sports town when you consider this result, and the fact that they've played for just one championship during this time (the '98 Caps). Again, this provides an explanation for the D.C. area going crazy over Alex Ovechkin.
Now, finally we get to Toronto. Let's break this thing down:
MLB: 0 / 14 - This will be 15 in just a few months, the only saving grace is the strike from 1994 that saved the city another year of ineptitude. Stuck in a division with the Red Sox and Yankees (and even the Rays), I can't see a playoff berth coming any time soon unless the team switches divisions or MLB moves away from an unbalanced schedule (and, quick lesson: The Jays management doesn't want either of those things to happen... they'd rather get the increased gate receipts from a bunch of home games against Boston and New York rather than, you know, have more than a 0.01% chance of making the playoffs.
NBA: 5 / 14 - The Raptors haven't been as bad of a franchise as some people would like you to believe. If you accept the fact that most expansion teams will require three or four years to get off the ground, then all of a sudden, five playoff appearances over the last decade doesn't seem all that bad. Here's the tricky part of this analysis though, because the team has won only one playoff series in 14 years of operation, meaning they've never been a serious title contender. Are they on that path now? I think that's still up for debate, but they should add another playoff appearance to the resume after this season.
NHL: 9 / 15 - The only saving grace that keeps this city from being downright embarrassing is the performance of the Quinn / Sundin / Joseph era Maple Leafs. Who would have thought we would look back on that era fondly. But again, were they serious Stanley Cup contenders? Or let's put it another way, look at all the other big-spending teams from this era: Detroit (15/15), Colorado (11/13), Philadelphia (13/15), Dallas (12/15) all have avoided major rebuilding (well, until now for Colorado). Why were the Leafs the only big-spending team that couldn't make the playoffs on a truly consistent basis, or turn their spending into at least one appearance in the Cup Final?
CONCLUSION
So here's the way I choose to look at this: Toronto is the worst sports city in North America. They're the only city that fails in both of these tests. Look at the cities in the basement with them in today's analysis:
Cleveland has been to a World Series, the NBA Finals, and is poised to win an NBA title sooner rather than later. Chicago has won a World Series, played in a Super Bowl, and won a boatload of NBA titles. Washington has been to a Stanley Cup Final, and has the best player in hockey playing in their city. Tampa Bay has been to a World Series, and won both a Stanley Cup and a Super Bowl. All of these cities have had at least something to get excited about over the last 15 or so years.
Then take a look at the analysis from earlier in the week: Atlanta has gone a while without a title, but they've got a perennial contender in baseball, and two teams on the upswing in football and basketball. Milwaukee / Green Bay is in a bit of a depressing state, but they still have a football team that contends more often than not.
Meanwhile, Minneapolis-St. Paul, the only area with a longer title appearance drought than Toronto, has been a much more consistent playoff performer (44%), and has had a couple teams that were true title contenders (Cunningham-Carter-Moss Vikings, Garnett-Cassell-Sprewell Timberwolves). And as I said the other day, I think the Twins & Vikings have a better shot of erasing their title game drought than any team currently residing in the GTA.
All in all, this has been a pretty depressing couple hours of work for me. What's next? I think we need to examine why Toronto is the worst performing major sports city in North America. Does it have to do with management? Fan support (or a lack thereof)? Geographical considerations? We shall see.
